General Meeting Information
Date: February 26,
2024
Time: 2:30-4:00 PM
Location: MLC 255
This meeting will be held HyFlex, meaning anyone can participate in-person or online. To join remotely, see the Zoom information at the bottom of this page.
The FHDA District Academic Senate (DAS) serves as the voice of the Academic Senates of the Foothill-De Anza Community College District. It is composed of all faculty at Foothill and De Anza Colleges, and is represented by the DAS Executive Committee, consisting of the Foothill and De Anza Academic Senate Officers and Senators.
-
Agenda
Time Topic Purpose Discussion Leader 2:30-2:35 1. Welcome and Introductions
Public CommentsI Maurer 2:35-3:45 2. Establishing a District Academic Senate position on Regular & Substantive Interaction (RSI) and other Online Education Requirements I/D/A Maurer, Woodbury, Villanueva, Meezan, Capurso 2a. Context setting (AP 4105) and goals for today 2b. Models for faculty training & preparation in RSI & Accessibility 2c. Models to ensure courses are accessible 2d. Models to ensure RSI will take place (the “plan” for RSI)
De Anza2e. Models to ensure is taking place (the “review” for RSI) 2f. Other Issues? Related Documents:
AP 4105
RSI Crosswalk-FHDA Discussion
Foothill Amendment to RSI Documentation Model
De Anza Online Training Certification Proposal3:45-4:00 Next Steps
I/D
Maurer, Woodbury, Villanueva, Perino 4:00 Adjournment
Maurer A = Action
D = Discussion
I = Information -
Minutes
Welcome and Introductions
Kathryn Maurer, FHDA (District) Academic Senate President, welcomed the Foothill and the De Anza Senates to the special joint meeting. Introductions around the room and those attending online.
Public Comments
Mary Donahue: Voter turnout is really low for this election, especially among students. She reminded everyone to encourage students to vote.
Establishing a District Academic Senate position on Regular & Substantive Interaction (RSI) and other Online Education Requirements
Context setting (AP 4105) and goals for the meeting
Kathryn Maurer explained that AP4105 has been approved by both Senates. Both colleges have been discussing and working on implementation plans in their respective senates and online education teams. The colleges are meeting jointly to discuss and propose a district wide position that will identify items for FA negotiation.
AP4105 is a legally required policy that addresses compliance with federal regulations for Distance Education and Correspondence Education.According to the policy: All distance education is subject to the requirements of Title 5 and to the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act. The policy states that online classes be reviewed and certified to meet the required RSI (Regular and Substantive Interaction) and Accessibility standards.
AP4105 has been a challenge as well as opportunity for both colleges to understand and define the requirements. They have been working with their respective online teams to develop training, certification, and evaluation for compliance and implementation.
Voltaire Villanueva and Erik Woodbury, Senate Presidents for Foothill and DeAnza, expressed their appreciation for all the discussion so far on the subject. They asked for tolerance for ambiguity as well as flexibility in working together to review and discuss the proposed models to be presented by both colleges.
Models for faculty training & preparation in RSI & Accessibility
Allison Lenkeit Meezan (Foothill) and James Capurso (De Anza) presented the following powerpoint RSI Crosswalk-FHDA Discussion
On RSI
…an instructor is responsible for promptly and proactively engaging in substantive interaction with the student
The district shall provide training and ensure that faculty teaching distance education courses shall be adequately prepared.
…instructors assigned to teach a distance education course section should be prepared to teach online in accordance with college procedures for obtaining agreed upon training. Prior to assigning a distance education course, the division dean shall verify the faculty have received current and sufficient training.
On Accessibility
Each section of a course in which the instructional time is conducted in part or in whole through distance education will comply with all applicable accessibility requirements outlined in state and federal regulations
Four Documentation Items Required by AP 4105
- Course complies with accessibility requirements set out in state and federal regulations
- Sufficient training for the faculty member
- How RSI will take place
- Ensuring that RSI is taking place
Allison and James presented the respective Foothill and De Anza proposals for training and documentation. The Foothill proposal focused on RSI and Accessibility. The De Anza proposal included Course Design and Assessment Training. See slides for details on the proposals and plans.
The goal of the discussion was to come to some agreements on how to meet the AP4015 requirements.
Foothill and De Anza have identified different training outcomes.
Format
There were discussions, agreement, and a motion on the training format.
Mary Donahue motioned that the training should be available to faculty in the district in both modalities, synchronous and asynchronous. Seconded by Erik Woodbury. No objections. Motion approved by both Senates.
Provide sufficient training
The district shall provide training and ensure that faculty teaching
distance education courses shall be adequately prepared.
Foothill and De Anza have different training, documentation, and certification plans. See slides.
There was much discussion and clarification on what is required at both colleges for the first time and continuing online faculty.
What was the requirement before?
What are the new requirements?
What does someone need to do to teach online for the first time?
What does online faculty need to do to continue teaching online?
What is the timeline for fulfilling the requirements?
What is the minimum requirement?
What ongoing training is required?
Kate Jordahl in chat: Rather than asking what is the least we can do perhaps we should ask what faculty need to succeed.
Carolyn Holcroft in chat: We have minimum qualifications to teach in a discipline. Our standards there are pretty high. I'm thinking about this discussion as determining the minimum qualifications to teach online (at FHDA) and I hope our standards will be high for those, too. It sort of seems like our min quals for a discipline is a master's or PhD but we may be considering min quals to teach online akin to a short survey-level course.
There were agreements and reactions to both statements in the room and online.
However, there is a need to define minimum, since anything over the minimum would require compensation.
Kathryn Maurer: The desired outcome for this meeting was to reach some commonality between the two colleges. The district is at risk of losing funding if it is out of compliance with AP4105. Therefore, the colleges and the district must implement plans to ensure accessibility and RSI.
Foothill has developed a model for Online Certification, one being developed at De Anza. At De Anza the Canvas Certification is separate from Online Certification.
What is sufficient training?
There's a difference between teaching people the concepts and then actually supporting them as they apply those concepts.Have in place a way to check the accessibility of an entire course. Provide support to faculty who are trying to make it accessible. It could be something that goes on over an entire quarter as they teach to provide the support that faculty need to create the ideal course.
Discussion on Certification and Ongoing Certification
Ongoing training and further development in online education
What do faculty need to know?
Cheryl Balm motioned “In order for faculty to teach online at the district one must be trained in accessibility, interaction, course design, and assessment”
Mary Pape seconded. No objections. Motion approved by both Senates.
Thanks to Allison and James for presenting and leading the discussion.
Related Documents:
Foothill Amendment to RSI Documentation Model
De Anza Online Training Certification Proposa
Next Steps
It was recommended that the Senate meet again to continue the discussion.
Adjournment
Attendance
De Anza
In person
Erik Woodbury, Patty Guitron, So Kam Lee
Cheryl Balm, Sam Bliss*, Catie Cadge-Moore, Mary Donahue, Cecilia Hui, Elsa Jimenez-Samayoa, Shagun Kaur, Lisa Mesh, Anna Nguyen, Liliana Rivera, Mary Pape, Christian Rodriguez, Jayanti Roy, Lakshmikanta "LK" Sengupta, Ravjeet Singh, Li Wei Sun, James Tallent, Felisa Vilaubi, Catherina Wong,*Lydia Wong
Online
Kevin Glapion, Lauren Gordon, Lydia Hearn*, Mark Landefeld, Sherwin Mendoza
Absent
Mirsaeid Abolghasemi, *Deborah Armstrong, Sheldon Fields, Vernon Gallegos, Rusty Johnson, Glynn Wallis
Foothill
In person
Voltaire Villanueva, Ben Kaupp, Robert Cormia
Michael Chang, Tracee Cunningham, Brian Evans, Stacy Gleixner, Robert Hartwell, Julie Jenkins, Allison Lenkeit Meezan, Mona Rawal, Eric Reed, Leticia Serna,
Online
Rocio Giraldez Betron, Stephanie Chan, Sara Cooper, Carolyn Holcroft, Julie Jenkins, Kate Jordahl, Patrick Morriss, Rita O'Loughlin, Katy Ripp, Kerri Ryer, Destiny Rivera, Stephan Schnell, Adiel Velasquez
Absent
Joshua Agupugo, Ajani Byrd, Rachelle Campbell, Roxanne Cnudde, Ana Maravilla, Frank Niccoli
Meeting URL: https://fhda-edu.zoom.us/j/83439477181?pwd=XIIaaHHSOgnk34hqixqxaXY0EwQOPU.1
Meeting ID: 834 3947 7181
Passcode: 996594
Member | Remote Location | In District? |
Mary Donahue (PT) | MLC 243, 21250 Stevens Creek Blvd, Cupertino, CA 95014 | Yes |
Mark Landefeld (PE & Athletics) | PE 51a, 21250 Stevens Creek Blvd, Cupertino, CA 95014 | Yes |
Mirsaeid Abolghasemi | 101 W.Weddell Dr., Sunnyvale, CA 94089 | Yes |
Lauren Gordon | F31G, 21250 Stevens Creek Blvd, Cupertino, CA 95014 | Yes |
Cecilia Hui | 1230 S Blaney Ave, San Jose, CA 95129 | Yes |
Kevin Glapion | RSS 141, 21250 Stevens Creek Blvd, Cupertino, CA 95014 | Yes |
Sherwin Mendoza | MCC-14, 21250 Stevens Creek Blvd, Cupertino, CA 95014 | Yes |
Patrick Morriss | 12345 El Monte Road, Room 1929, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022 | No |
Katy Ripp | 106 Del Carlo Ct. Los Gatos, CA 95032 | No |
Rocio Giraldez Betron | 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla CA 92093 | No |
Roxanne Cnudde | 800 Creek Drive, Boulder Creek, CA 95006 | No |